6 Best Cardigans For Fat Guys and Big Dudes

Cardigans are one of the more divisive garments in the world of men’s clothing.

Okay, that might make things sound a little more serious than they are but the fact is when most people think of cardigans they probably think of good ole’ Mr. Rogers.

And he wasn’t exactly a big guy.

So can fat guys and big dudes make cardigans work?

Heck yeah, they can!

But as with anything else, fat guys and big dudes need to make a few more style considerations before they dive right in.

In most cases, bigger guys will want to avoid a deeper v-cut that’s common with cardigans and instead opt for a more natural cut or a collar that gives the cardigan a more masculine look. Additionally, bigger guys will want to avoid cardigans that are too snug as many of these can have a bit of a taper to them. Both of these common cardigan features can appear feminine on a bigger guy’s body.

We’ll dive deep into everything you need to know about picking out the perfect cardigan but if you want to just skip ahead and see what made the list you can see our favorites here:

Now let’s get started!

Let’s Define A Cardigan

Fashion is confusing.

The addition or subtraction of a button in the wrong spot and all of sudden you’re dealing with a completely different type of garment. So let’s make sure we’re using the same working definition for what a cardigan is before we dive into the rest of the info.

A cardigan is a long-sleeve, knitted garment similar to a sweater. But unlike a sweater, a cardigan is open on the front and includes several buttons, toggles, or even a zipper for closure. When it comes to buttons and toggles, there is usually significant spacing between each closure.

While some folks would exclude zippered cardigans from the traditional definition, we think this is a travesty. After all, the legendary Mr. Rogers wore a zipper cardigan and he pretty much put this garment on the map. So the zipper stays. 

Said another way, a cardigan is a sort of jacket and sweater combination. You take the more formal knit style of a sweater and combine it with an open face jacket and you’ve got a cardigan.

Now you know exactly what you’re getting into for the rest of this article.

What Should Fat Guys Look For In A Cardigan?

There’s a good reason why cardigans aren’t as popular as other clothing for fat guys- this look can be a little difficult to pull off.

But just like any other style, it can absolutely work for big guys with the right considerations so let’s break down what big dudes need to look for. One of our main concerns is avoiding a look that comes off as too feminine since many common features of cardigans for men are also shared with the versions made for women.

Keep in mind, these are also the same criteria I used to decide which cardigans made the list and which ones didn’t.

However, cardigans play by different rules.

Of course, a cardigan can also end up looking effeminate especially when you consider that cardigans are made with an emphasis towards both males and females. In other words, if you rock a deep v-neck with some man boobs it could look like you just grabbed something off the woman’s rack. Not great.

But the big difference is that you’re going to be wearing a shirt underneath and that can go a long way to offset the look of a v-neck. On top of that, cardigans have a wide range of v-neck styles with some of them being very deep and narrow. A deep and narrow v-neck is quite different from a wide v neck which quickly starts to look like a women’s garment.

So what’s the takeaway here?

If you carry a lot of your weight in your chest, it’s usually a good idea to play it safe and go for cardigans that use a more traditional collar. When it comes to cardigans, that means either a zipper or button that runs all the way up.

Another good option for any fat guy is a shawl-style collar which is a turned-over collar that ends up looking thicker. These collars break up the v-neck and make it look thinner.

That way you end up with a very deep but also very thin v-neck which prevents an accidental effeminate look. You can see a great example of this collar on this cardigan which is also one of my favorites and our pick for best sizing choices.

Your last choice is the traditional cardigan which can work for fat guys but if you’re not sure or you’re worried about some moob action then you can skip these.

We have a little of everything on this list but I’ve focused on traditional and shawl-style collars since they work best for most big guys.

Skip The Big Buttons

You’ll find both buttons, zippers and toggle-style closures on this list but we’re going to limit jumbo-sized or extra-large button closures. These can work for fat guys but depending on the rest of the cardigan and the overall outfit, these buttons can quickly create a more feminine look.

Best Cardigans For Fat Guys

Now that we know what we’re looking for, let’s look at the best cardigans for fat guys starting with our pick for best overall. Before we dive in, here’s a quick look at some of the top picks.

Best Overall: KingSize Men’s Big & Tall Shaker Knit Zip-Front Cardigan

Our best overall pick has everything big guys look for in a cardigan even if it’s a bit on the non-traditional side with a zipper closure.

But for fat guys, that can actually be a good thing.

First, a zipper means you don’t have to worry about that strained button look that can happen when cardigans are too tight on your belly. Second, a zipper also comes with a more traditional collar so you don’t have to worry about finding the right depth for your v-neck. Third, zipper closures gives the cardigan a more casual look which means you can get a lot more mileage out of this garment.

You can rock this cardigan with nice pair of big guy-friendly jeans for a more casual look or style up with a pair of khakis. Either way, this cardigan will work.

Still, it takes more than a zipper to grab the best overall spot from us.

When you throw in sizing options up to 8XL (including tall options), 6 different color options, and pricing that’s very easy on the budget it’s easy to see why this should be the first cardigan you check out.

Of course, the zipper isn’t for everyone, and if you have a more formal event to attend I suggest you check out some of the other more traditional cardigans below.

But if you like the look and feel of a more traditional shirt or sweater with all the class of a cardigan you can check out more reviews for this cardigan from King Size along with the latest price on Amazon by clicking here.

Best Sizing Options: KingSize Men’s Big & Tall Shaker Knit Shawl-Collar Cardigan Sweater

When it comes to finding the best sizing options, the folks at King Size deliver again. We’ve seen this brand several times, including on our list of the best sweaters for fat guys, so it’s no surprise to see them again.

Not only do they offer great clothing but it’s available in sizes that are large enough for big dudes and this classy cardigan is no different. Available up to 9XL, this cardigan is big enough that most guys will be able to find something that works or just pick up something with a looser style.

Once you find a size that works, you can also double down with 7 different color options to pick from.

However, this cardigan does partially break the deep v-neck rule but opening this cardigan up looks great so we’re bending the rule a bit here. Because of the thicker, shawl-style color this cardigan looks great left open and still doesn’t come off as too casual. Just make sure you match it with a nice belt if you’re leaving it open.

Keeping it closed levels up the formality but make sure you’re wearing a nicer shirt underneath to complete the look. The longer V-neck is also balanced out by the shawl collar which can help elongate your face and offset any negative effects of a deeper v-neck.

Lastly, it’s worth noting that this cardigan is made from 100% acrylic. That does help bring the price down but not all guys will be stoked about synthetic fabric. However, I have no problem recommending acrylic since it’s less likely to bunch up on your belly and helps keep the price down

It also helps that there are more than 600 five-star reviews backing this cardigan up. You can read some of those reviews and check the latest price on Amazon by clicking here.

 

Best Classic Cardigan: Harriton Pilbloc V-Neck Button Cardigan Sweater

Sometimes, you just want to stick with the classics and this simple cardigan from Harriton does exactly that. It’s a no-frills cardigan and you can see it paired with a nice dress shirt here.

You won’t find any fancy collars, closures, or elaborate knitting here. But you will find a comfortable, easy-on-the-budget cardigan with sizes up to 6XL for big guys. It isn’t as deep of a v-neck as Mr. Rogers would have rocked but beyond that, it’s pretty darn close.

This isn’t a cardigan that you’d want to wear with a simple t-shirt and because of the v-neck, you’ll want to make sure you’re wearing a collar. At least, that’s assuming you’re going with the fully closed look and if you open all the buttons you can get away with a less formal garment underneath.

This is great for less formal or formal because of the simple design. The buttons are smaller and there’s no pockets or anything. Here’s a look at the size of the buttons compared to another top pick.

The only possible downside here is the acrylic fabric. There’s nothing wrong with acrylic fabric and it does help bring the price down but some guys simply won’t like the feel of it. It also may not be as breathable as some other options, but this is a thinner cardigan and that might not be an issue.

Still, considering that this cardigan isn’t likely to ever actually touch your skin (on account of your undershirt or dress shirt) it shouldn’t be too much of an issue.

I also like knitting around the edges of this cardigan. It really ties everything together, plus it gives it a little shape. That’s really advantageous when you’re wearing a cardigan as a big guy, because you don’t really want a flowy cardigan. You can see the knitting in this picture.

You take a closer look at all 10 colors, the many 5-star reviews, and of course today’s price on Amazon by clicking here.

 

Most Unique Colors For Big Guys: X Ray Button Down Cardigan Sweater

Sometimes, you don’t want a solid color or you want more options. And, when it comes to cardigans for fat guys, that seems to be difficult. But it doesn’t have to be with these cardigans from X RAY.

There aren’t a ton of cardigans out there that cater to fat guy sizes. But, I’m happy to report this cardigan is available in sizes all the way up to a 6X.

The buttons are well-placed and well-sized so that they don’t cross the line into feminine but still appear stylish. However, they are a little larger on some of them than you might want, so here’s a look at how the buttons on the gray XRAY sweater compare to those on the Harrington sweater above.

Some of the patterns are also bold instead of plain. There are two-color options and you even have the choice between a traditional V-neck or a shawl neck for a little more warmth. I love the shawl option, here’s a look at how the collars differ between this and a more traditional V-neck.

I will say that you’ll want to pay attention when ordering. In addition to all the color options, some styles have different buttons and you want to be sure you like the style that you buy.

I really love the olive and burgundy colors and they will pair with just about any type of pants, including jeans or khakis.

Plus, they are made of a fabric blend that leaves them soft to the touch and warm, without sacrificing breathability. You can see how the entire sweater is made of this soft, breathable fabric blend here.

This is something you really want in any piece of clothing when you’re bigger, especially if you sweat a lot. And, the material has a little bit of stretch.

There aren’t a ton of reviews yet, but this cardigan is worth checking out and one of the few options that big guys have when it comes to stripes. You can check out some of the reviews and today’s prices on Amazon by clicking here.

 

Best Cashmere Blend For Fat Guys: Kallspin Men’s Cardigan Sweater

Cashmere is the cream of the crop when it comes to cardigans…but it’s also crazy expensive.

If that wasn’t enough, it’s also almost impossible to find big and tall sizing options in a cashmere cardigan.

That’s why I usually suggest going for a cashmere blend, especially one that has wool in it. Not only will you save a ton compared to the real thing but you’ll still get the comfort and stylish look of cashmere at a price that isn’t going to break the bank.

And that’s exactly where this great-looking cardigan from Kallspin comes into the picture and it’s available in up to 4XL along with 12 different colors. Here’s a look at the cardigan over one of our recommendations for best dress shirt for fat guys.

The combination of the cut and fabric blend also gives this a much more formal look which is often what you want from a cardigan. But you still have the option of leaving it open and sporting a more casual look if you need to match the style of the occasion.

The fabric combination of wool, cashmere and synthetic fabrics is also lightweight but will still keep you warm. After all, we aren’t just wearing our cardigan to look good and we need to protect ourselves from the weather too.

While you do have 12 colors to choose from, you’re not going to find anything too crazy here and all the colors will line up with the classic look you’d expect from a cardigan. I also love the simple pockets on the front that you can see here.

Keep in mind, there is a deep v-neck here so you will need to wear a nice shirt underneath. Every big guy is different but if you carry a lot of your weight in your chest, then going for a v-neck this deep might not be a good play and instead, you should check out one of the higher closure options. Here’s a look at how deep the V is compared to the Harrington cardigan.

But if you’re ready to rock the deep v-neck and a great cardigan you can check out all 12 colors, read more reviews and see today’s price on Amazon by clicking here.

 

Best Cold Weather Cardigan For Fat Dudes: Lief Nelson Knitted Turtleneck Cardigan

Sometimes, you want a cardigan that offers a little more for warmth than the average cardigan. And, this turtleneck-style cardigan from Lief Nelson certainly gets the job done.

This doesn’t have any bright colors or multi-color designs, but it is available in 8 color options in almost every neutral color you could want, plus a dark blue option.

When it comes to working for big guys, you have sizing options up to 5XL.

Beyond the unique look, which is what really makes this cardigan stand out, I’m a big fan of the collar design for colder weather. It buttons all the way up your neck for warmth, plus it has a thicker design.

At the time of writing, there aren’t many reviews on Amazon, but those that they do have are pretty positive. Plus, I can tell you myself that you will look sharp in this cardigan.

You can take a closer look at the design, see the available reviews and check today’s price on Amazon by clicking here.

 

Closing Thoughts

Cardigans are a great choice for fat guys and big dudes but they’re often passed up. In many cases, I think this has to do with the deep v-neck that can turn bad if it’s not styled appropriately.

But not only can a fat guy make a deep v look great, but they can also do so a lot easier than you think. The cardigan look is also shifting away from Mr. Rogers and more towards a mainstay of modern, trendy, and casual fashion even for big guys.

Even if that’s not your thing, you still have plenty of cardigan options that either use a shawl collar to minimize the v-neck look or use a more traditional collar altogether.

No matter what your preference, fat guys can find a great cardigan that works for their body type.

What do you think? Did you find one you liked?